Listen to this post · 13 min
0:00

What do Elvis Presley, Chuck Berry, Little Richard, and Buddy Holly have in common?

American artists. Rock ‘n’ roll legends. In their own ways, they changed music and pop culture during their years at the top of the charts.

Oh, and they were all robbed.

Call the Sheriff!

Four kids from Liverpool, England, stole their tunes, their style, and eventually, their place on those charts.

The Beatles, before they became the Beatles, were copycats. They’d buy the records and play the songs along with their idols. They’d practice until they knew the tunes cold.

Ian Leslie tells the story of Paul McCartney’s transformation. “When he first tried to emulate a Little Richard whooo, he couldn’t escape his self-consciousness. What was a well-brought-up boy from Liverpool, England, doing trying to imitate a wild-sounding Black man from America? Then one day he forgot himself and just did it, and it felt amazing, like he had jumped out of his skin.”

John and the guys must have liked how it sounded, because a Little Richard-style whooo makes appearances in a number of early Beatles songs—“I Saw Her Standing There” at the top of that list.

The Beatles and Little Richard
[The Beatles and Little Richard]

But the guys were changing. They didn’t want to be an “oldies” band. So they started looking for more obscure songs they could make their own. Country and western, rhythm and blues, instrumentals, ballads. What could they find that audiences hadn’t heard? What could they dig up in an old crate that would impress their bandmates?

Leslie again, “They could listen to a song one or two times and not just remember it but swallow it, digest it, absorb it into their bloodstream. Every song they played became a Beatles song; they stole but never copied.”

Their palate was expanding. Now it was the Cookies, the Shirelles, the Ronettes. Not a single name, an individual entertainer standing in front of a backing band, but a group. A blend of voices. John and Paul were strongly influenced by the harmonizing of the Everly Brothers, but their incorporation of George, creating a three-part chorus, and their use of “ahhs” and “oohs” to back the lead line, were on loan from doo-wop and girl groups—the Chantels’ Arlene Smith in particular.

How many original ideas are really out there? How many do you need?

You don’t need to invent everything from scratch. You can borrow ideas. Digest them. Absorb them into your bloodstream. Figure out what works, what doesn’t, and what might…work for you.

You don’t need an original idea. You need an original relationship with the idea.

The goal is to get good enough to know what works, understand why it works, and eventually figure out what works for you.

Once you understand something, you can change it, break it, and rebuild it in your own voice.

I learned a version of this lesson through investing.

Make It Yours

When I began investing, I loved a particular version, a specific point of view. So I borrowed the playbook whole hog. I was a subscriber to The Motley Fool, the stock-picking service started by brothers Tom and David Gardner. I liked their perspective, their material, and I welcomed their weekly stock picks.

But mostly, I enjoyed reading why they picked those particular stocks. Most of them I’d never heard of, and plenty were duds, but they led me to more than a few winners too.

And even though I was beating the market with their help, I had an issue. When the economy turned and the stocks started heading south, I had no conviction. I’d borrowed theirs—and gave it right back when the going got tough.

I’d buy and sell. Sell and buy. Trade in and out of positions. Sometimes the same positions. Why? Why couldn’t I stick with Atlassian or Old Dominion?

I think it’s the same reason you can’t stick with a diet you found in Men’s Health. You don’t own it. You’ve got no accountability to it. It’s theirs, not yours—and without understanding the principles underneath it, it’s hard to fully get on board.

Then one day, listening to David Gardner’s Rule Breaker Investing podcast, I got one of the better lessons of my life. He and his cohosts walked through the scoring system he used to rate the risk of a business, based on what mattered to him.

It’s fantastic.

David and Tom Gardner
[David and Tom Gardner]

Part of the beauty of that scoring system is that it’s partly subjective. Profitability and cash flow are easy to score—anyone can pull those numbers. But branding? Culture? Moat? That’s on you to work out. Different people land on different scores for the same company, and that’s the point. That might not sound great to a tip taker, but to a homework doer, it’s ideal.

So I started using this scoring system, and you know what, after doing the homework, I found some very fine businesses that I had conviction in. And more to the point, when they had a bad quarter, I could stick with them, because I understood the business well enough to believe the market was missing the boat.

My scoring started with that template, but it’s changed over the years. I read all the finance books and then some. New information, new knowledge, new criteria. I was boiling things down, crystallizing a system I believed in. And it was only after doing that work, finding my system, that I really gained the conviction to go big on the businesses I believed in. And stick with them. I wasn’t second-guessing the Motley Fool picks or Gardner’s grade anymore.

I trusted mine.

And that confidence is what I needed. To jump in with both feet, and to eventually leave my job.

Besides, how many great ideas does any service really have? When you’re paid to deliver five stocks every Friday, guess what, you’ll send them no matter the market. I can’t recall a single email saying, just hang tight, nothing to buy this week.

Advice can be useful. But there’s a real difference between borrowing an idea and copying someone’s actions wholesale.

And it happens outside of investing too.

Parrots and People

Remember Steve Jobs’ turtleneck? He rocked that thing every single day. As the story goes, the turtleneck saved him time and energy. It saved him from decision fatigue. Now he could focus a few more neurons on the iPod.

Others followed suit, and the turtleneck industry rejoiced.

But even Jobs would tell you the turtleneck wasn’t the point. The whole idea was avoiding unnecessary decision-making.

Zuck ran with the idea. Not turtlenecks, but hoodies (Zuck has since abandoned his hoodies, and with that, has made all sorts of questionable decisions. Coincidence?)

If you wear a black turtleneck every day in hopes of creating one of the world’s most admired companies, you’re parroting.

Steve Jobs and his black turtleneck
[Steve Jobs and his black turtleneck]

But the idea? The meme? It’s not too bad. Save some cognitive cycles and apply those toward your aspirations. That is an idea that is worthwhile. Especially if you can do it in your own way.

If I’d known that jeans and a tee, with some chucks, was all I required back at Highline High, I could have saved myself a lot of time and angst. If I’d only known that a three on the sides, four on top was all the hairstyle I needed, I’d have saved time, money, and might have found a date or two.

And if my old firm had built a culture around borrowing and learning ideas from McKinsey and Accenture instead of leaning into Bruno Magli and those fat jock-knotted ties, I can only imagine how the business would have thrived.

David Deutsch articulates the difference between reciting lines and understanding them.

A child learning a language doesn’t memorize every word exactly. The kid pulls out the meaning. The meaning is the meme. That’s what we’re after.

We might forget the phrasing, but if we grok the meaning, mission accomplished.

A parrot can’t do that. Deutsch writes, “If a parrot had copied snatches of [Karl] Popper’s voice at a lecture, it would certainly have copied them with his Austrian accent: parrots are incapable of copying an utterance without its accent.” It can mimic the sound and carry none of the meaning. Copy the accent—the turtleneck, the five picks a week, the exact words—and you’re a parrot. Find the meaning underneath it, and you’ve got something more human. More useful too.

Gardner started out by handing me his picks. But in the end, he did much more. He handed me a way of thinking about businesses.

When the Beatles broke up, fans around the world were heartbroken. The guys, despite their hard candy shell, were busted up as well.

But look what they took with them. Everything they needed, and then some—enough to keep making music on their own, with new collaborators, in styles nobody would have predicted from those four kids playing tunes note for note.

They were still breaking the rules.

If you enjoyed this post, please share it with a friend.


Discover more from Win With Flynn

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

What do you think?

I’m Dave

Welcome to the Flynnternet, where we share An Idea, Every Monday.

We’ll travel across business, sports, pop culture, and everyday life to tell stories that explain our human operating system.

Incentives, human nature, perspective, and the small decisions that compound.

Let’s connect


Keep the Flynnternet Wild and Free

— or —

— or —

Listen to the BlogCast