Listen to this post · 15 min
0:00

“What would Dave do?”

That’s a phrase I’ve heard running around some friend groups. A chunk of the extended family too.

And I’ll be straight with you, my dozens of readers: I have concerns.

Do what I do? Quit your job to become a blogger? OMG, no! That’s not advice I’d ever give—not because blogging isn’t cool and sexy (it is), but it’s not for everybody. Not like brushing your teeth or improving your squat.

What I would advocate for, since you’re asking, is quitting your job to do something you enjoy, that brings you meaning, that you wake up thinking about. On Hard Knocks, Seahawks Coach Mike Macdonald tells the team what it takes to make it in the NFL: “Everything you’ve got, all the time.”

Everything? All the time? That sounds like a lot. But it’s the real answer behind a lot of professions.

People don’t want to hear it though. It’s wearing overalls and looks like work. Their preference? A tip. A little nugget, some advice, or a suggestion.

A shortcut? Now we’re talking.

And this is the issue with “What would Dave do?” or what would anyone else do for that matter.

“Tips Are for Waiters”

Jim Cramer gets a lot of shit. Some is deserved, but most of it’s not. He’s been on air five days a week for two decades, taking calls from kids and grandmas and “the everyman.” He interviews CEOs and educates the masses.

Mostly from memory, he’ll give callers a micro analysis on the business of their choosing and then hammer his BUY BUY BUY or SELL SELL SELL button before moving on to the next segment.

He has been telling viewers that Apple is a hold, not a trade, for twenty years.

His dog is named Nvidia.

In August of 2007, he went on the air and screamed that the Federal Reserve “knows nothing!”—and Atlanta Fed president Dennis Lockhart laughed at him.

But still, the internet does a wonderful job of capturing his bad takes and holding them over his head. The Inverse Cramer Index, a fictional fund that does the opposite of his advice has had some great short-term returns.

But the phrase I remember him for is worth remembering. He tells you that “tips are for waiters.” Meaning—don’t buy the damn thing just because he punched that BUY button inside of a twelve-second, made for TV, segment of markets-as-entertainment.

If you did your homework on Cramer, you know, reading his books, you’d learn a lot.

  • Don’t buy (or sell) all at once. Scale in and out of your positions.
  • Buy the best-of-breed. Don’t be afraid to pay up for quality.
  • Buy damaged stocks, not damaged companies.
  • Diversification is the only “free lunch”

Hmmmm, that all sounds pretty solid to me.

He calls it “buy and homework,” as opposed to “buy and hold.” That’s the thesis of his career, but it gets buried under the viral moments.

And he knows it.

Most people just want to take his gut reaction and run with it.

Buy Bristol Myers, sell Palo Alto Networks, call it a day.

The problem is, when you go with Cramer’s gut, you never develop your own. And the truth is, buying stocks is easy, holding them is a whole lot harder.

Two Thumbs Down

Reservoir Dogs got two thumbs down from Siskel and Ebert. Even if Tarantino is not your cup of tea, that movie is fucking great. But for many, those thumbs up, thumbs down ratings were gospel. You might wander into the pub to hang with some friends and parrot that review, tell your buddies it’s a pass, and suggest you all go see Junior instead. Because Siskel and Ebert said it was “cute.”  After Twins, who didn’t want to see Schwarzenegger and DeVito on the silver screen again. I know I did.

But, you skip Reservoir Dogs and you’d be missing out on a great film and a cultural turning point. The early work from a truly genius movie maker.

On the flip side, if one of those buddies, a real friend, says, “WTF are you talking about? Junior? Are you brain dead?” How strongly would you hold your belief in Siskel and Ebert?

If you go a layer deeper, Ebert’s review had some legitimate critiques. Style without substance. Not enough character development to go along with gratuitous violence. Fair enough. You read that, go see the movie from an “obviously talented writer-director,” and come to your own conclusions.

But, and I hate to break this to you, most people don’t want to come to their own conclusions. They want to fast forward to someone else’s.

Barbecues on Long Island

Josh Brown of the Compound and Friends talks about tips, advice, and the barbecue phenomenon on Long Island. He is a talking head on CNBC, a very well-known name in financial markets, and he avoids most of the weekend barbecues because he just knows he’ll be asked all the usual brain-dead questions.

Did Nvidia top?

Is Salesforce a buy at these levels?

And while he loves talking shop, he’s found that there is quite a double standard amongst media predictions.

If Terry Bradshaw says that the Washington Commanders will beat the Miami Dolphins this weekend, and he’s wrong, welp, that’s just the way the cookie crumbles. But if Brown says Google is a buy, and it drops 2.5%, he’ll never hear the end of it.

Still, it’s become popular (and easy) to “follow-along” invest.

Each quarter, the biggest funds in the world release their 13Fs, their public filings that outline their biggest buys and sells. You can just do what Bill Ackman does, do what Stanley Druckenmiller does, or for those who love pain, do what Cathie Wood does.

Do these people want you following along? Do they want to be your stock picker? If they do, if they’re really looking for Tom in Tacoma to follow-along with their investments, be careful.

Borrowed conviction has a short shelf life.

Tip money spends fast, and tips in the market, the gym, or LinkedIn spend even faster. You lose confidence quickly if you haven’t done the homework. If you don’t understand what’s behind the tip.

So how can we get closer to the mark? Develop our own gut? Our own conviction? By taking Cramer’s actual advice: doing the homework.

And doing the homework doesn’t mean finding someone better to copy.

As I continue to build out the Flynnternet, I get ideas from friends and readers and listeners. Tips are abundant.

I’m very cautious about adding. Adding anything at all. When I started the blogcast, I’d wrestled with the idea for over a year. I didn’t want to add any activities to my schedule that would be draining. I don’t want to wake up on a Sunday, dreading Monday, because I didn’t have a post or a recording ready to go.

That’s the sinking feeling you’ll get when you borrow ideas, tips, instead of forming your own.

The Sunday scaries, however you choose to avoid them, are “what Dave would actually do.” But notice there is no specific advice or direction in that statement. The world, your world, is your oyster. Don’t borrow mine. It comes with a healthy dose of grit.

The $5 checklist, the Somewhat Motivation Journal, these exist for the same reason. They’re not answers, they’re lenses, they’re homework.

Tips? Well, you can’t avoid them completely. But when they land in your lap, don’t rush toward implementation. Go and find out why they’re supposed to work, see how they might work for you, and build some conviction of your own.

If they’re borrowed, they’ll come due, earlier than you might think.

If you enjoyed this post, please share it with a friend.


Discover more from Win With Flynn

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

2 responses to “Tips Are for Waiters”

  1. Kerry Lohr Avatar
    Kerry Lohr

    What are distressed stocks?

    1. itsdaveflynn Avatar

      Stocks that are being sold off for reasons outside of their business results and future prospects.

      Apple selling off 30% when COVID came to town. People overreacted when they closed all their stores. But everyone still needed phones…more than they ever did.

      Distressed or broken business would be something like Blockbuster or Yahoo or JCPenny.

      The trick is, can you spot the difference in the moment.

What do you think?

I’m Dave

Welcome to the Flynnternet, where we share An Idea, Every Monday.

We’ll travel across business, sports, pop culture, and everyday life to tell stories that explain our human operating system.

Incentives, human nature, perspective, and the small decisions that compound.

Let’s connect


Keep the Flynnternet Wild and Free

— or —

— or —

Listen to the BlogCast